Dangers of Progressivism (feat. Jim Dalrymple)

Get our Premium podcast feed featuring all the breakout sessions from the RENEW gathering early. 

https://reallifetheologypodcast.supercast.com/ 

Today’s episode will help us recognize and address the subtle dangers of progressive Christianity while strengthening our faith through clear theology and intentional discipleship.

Navigating Progressive Christianity: Insights and Warnings for Modern Believers

In this comprehensive episode, we explore the intersection of progressive Christianity and contemporary cultural philosophies, drawing lessons from Paul's letters to Timothy. Participants will gain insights into diagnosing false teachings, the influence of modern social theories, and the importance of maintaining a solid theological foundation. Through metaphors like health and construction, this discussion contrasts authentic biblical teachings with the 'comfort gospel' and celebrity culture in the church. The episode underscores the transformative power of true faithfulness versus flashiness and warns against the dangers of syncretism observed in different cultural contexts. Episodes include practical exercises, historical insights, and references to prominent figures like Alyssa Childers. Join us to navigate the challenges posed by progressive Christianity and ensure a rooted and substantive faith.

Check out RENEW.org eBooks: https://renew.org/resources/free-ebooks/ 

Check out RENEW.org Events: https://renew.org/resources/events/ 

Interested in more content from RENEW? Sign up for our newsletter: https://renew.org/resources/newsletter-sign-up/ 

Key Takeaways 

00:00 Introduction and Workshop Overview

00:18 Metaphors for Understanding Progressive Christianity

01:51 Prayer and Biblical Lens for Diagnosing False Teaching

02:39 Classroom Insights on False Teachers

05:42 Speculations vs. Stewardship

07:09 False Teachings and Modern Contexts

11:07 Paul's Teachings on False Doctrine

14:51 Syncretism and Progressive Theology

26:19 Diagnosing Modern Progressive Theology

29:10 Critiquing Higher Criticism and Theological Bias

30:23 The Influence of Postmodernism and Neo-Marxism

31:43 Navigating Theological Fluidity and Individualism

34:21 Culture as Canon and the Role of Cancel Culture

36:47 The Heart as Guide and the Problem with Self-Reliance

38:56 Tolerance, Activism, and Deconstruction

42:33 Caution in Confronting Sin and Overreaction

52:08 The Importance of Discipleship and Discipline

56:25 Final Thoughts and Prayer

See below for a longer description:

This episode features a workshop by Jim Dalrymple on the challenges of progressivism in Christianity. Dalrymple begins by acknowledging the post-lunch time slot and sets a welcoming tone. He explores the difficulties of defining and diagnosing progressivism, using two metaphors from Paul’s letters to Timothy: health and homebuilding.

Dalrymple stresses the need for clear theological definitions, comparing progressive Christianity to medical diagnostics and home reconstruction. He opens with prayer, focusing on spiritual resilience in a changing society.

Drawing from his experience teaching 1 Timothy and 2 Timothy at Ozark Christian College, Dalrymple uses a visual metaphor—like a detective's crime board—to highlight the traits of false teachers and link them to today’s progressive Christianity. He examines 1 Timothy 1:3-7, contrasting speculation with stewardship, and warns against modern movements like the health and wealth gospel and the comfort gospel, which mirror historical challenges faced by the church.

Dalrymple then shifts to the metaphor of homebuilding, cautioning against deconstructing faith without rebuilding on biblical foundations. He critiques the tendency to replace core doctrines with speculative or culturally convenient ideas.

He addresses the delicate balance between gentleness and confrontation when responding to false teachings, and observes how progressive Christianity often seeks recognition, power, and controversy, drawing examples from past and present trends.

Next, Dalrymple discusses the broader cultural influences—humanism, skepticism, Darwinism, naturalism, and postmodernism—that have shaped progressive theology, arguing that these secular philosophies have diluted Christian teachings.

He identifies key traits of progressive Christianity: elevating culture as the ultimate authority, following subjective feelings, prioritizing tolerance above all else, and viewing activism as worship. He critiques the lack of clear doctrinal boundaries in the movement.

Dalrymple examines the motivations behind progressive beliefs, including cultural pressures, personal hurts, and the desire for platforms or pleasure, and warns against the deliberate or unintentional distortion of traditional theology.

He closes with practical advice, urging church leaders to focus on intentional discipleship and proper church discipline to safeguard doctrinal purity and restore those led astray by false teachings.

In summary, this workshop calls for vigilance in addressing the subtle dangers of progressive Christianity, combining scriptural analysis with practical steps for protecting and nurturing healthy church communities.

Be sure to like, subscribe and follow on social media! 

You can find us on:

Instagram: @the.renew.network 

Facebook: Renew.org 

Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@RENEWnetwork

Twitter: @therenewnetwork

TikTok: the.renew.network 

Rumble: https://rumble.com/c/RENEW